Romance & Pragmatism II: the Politics of Food
Romance & Pragmatism II: the Politics of Food
By Janine M. deManda
"I still very much doubt I could kill an animal for food, even if I've begun to believe a sustainable relationship with the earth can include eating meat."
~Julia Bloch
That quote is from an article in an American lesbian glossy written by someone whose formerly doctrinaire attitudes about lesbian and vegan purity have mellowed. {How nice for her.} The article is offensive in a lot of ways, not the least of which are the same ways in which just about every vegan/vegetarian I have ever encountered is offensive – in the complete disregard of issues of class privilege, in the all talk and no walk approach to politics, in the condescension generously offered to anyone with a different take on meat, in the complete disregard of the lived experience of a substantial majority of the world's population with regard to the availability of food, and perhaps most hypocritically, in the implicit assumption that homo sapiens are somehow superior to all other animals and therefore obliged to offer them a paternalism remarkably parallel to that offered by Whites to all their lesser cousins in the human family.
By Janine M. deManda
"I still very much doubt I could kill an animal for food, even if I've begun to believe a sustainable relationship with the earth can include eating meat."
~Julia Bloch
That quote is from an article in an American lesbian glossy written by someone whose formerly doctrinaire attitudes about lesbian and vegan purity have mellowed. {How nice for her.} The article is offensive in a lot of ways, not the least of which are the same ways in which just about every vegan/vegetarian I have ever encountered is offensive – in the complete disregard of issues of class privilege, in the all talk and no walk approach to politics, in the condescension generously offered to anyone with a different take on meat, in the complete disregard of the lived experience of a substantial majority of the world's population with regard to the availability of food, and perhaps most hypocritically, in the implicit assumption that homo sapiens are somehow superior to all other animals and therefore obliged to offer them a paternalism remarkably parallel to that offered by Whites to all their lesser cousins in the human family.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home