Monday, May 19, 2008

Femme on Fences

Femme on Fences

by Janine M. deManda

When I was growing up, I loathed and detested the color pink, white lace, frills, and absolutely anything I associated with femininity – even the word. In my world, femininity was about weakness and dependence, and those were two things I learned early from my ma that I should avoid at all costs. Climbing trees and collecting fossils and swimming in mudholes and creeks were high on my list of favorite activities. Of course, I also loved playing with barbies {yes, I was always ken, but I was also always at least one of the girls, too, and I did some amazing set and costume design in addition to writing most of the scripts}, and I detested baiting hooks and refused to gut my own fish. Still, I didn’t cry unless extremely provoked, and then not for long, and I could get the damn worm on the hook myself, thank you very much.

Now, I grew up working poor, so my notion of femininity as weak and dependent was very much informed by class. When I got to be a certain age and started wanting to show off my new cleavage and wear skintight jeans, I didn’t see that as contrary to my abhorrence of femininity. To my mind, these were expressions of female power role modeled by any number of hardass, take no shit women I’d grown up watching cope with more than I’d ever seen any man manage. What I didn’t want to be was the kind of simpering feminine creature I saw portrayed in the limited media outlets that made their way into our isolated rural backwater and embodied by women I didn’t know personally but sometimes saw around the county. That aside, though, I was more than ready to become a kick-ass, in-charge kinda grown woman, even if I was a few years shy of my majority.

When I went off to college a few years later, I had some jarring lessons about the differences between my ideals and the middle class norms that prevail in institutions of higher learning. Having already internalized enough classism to alter my speech patterns and apologize for my origins, I also started to let go of some of my flamboyance. I was helped along in this by a gem of a trash boy husband {ripe with his own internalized classism} acquired along the way who slipped his patriarchal misogyny past my naiveté badly disguised as liberal pro-feminism that “gave me permission” not to shave or wear make-up or revealing clothing. Thankfully, around the time I dropped out of grad school, I dropped him, too.

Back before I picked him up in the first place, I knew I was queer and polyamorous {though I didn’t have or use those words yet}, and I communicated about that with him. He said he understood and was supportive, and I believed him. {Turned out, he thought it was all a phase marrying him would snap me out of. Um, no.} In the midst of this morass, the light of feminism{s} was revealed to me. I latched on to it like a drowning sailor to a floating spar, and it helped me get my ass out of that sling.

Of course, I had a few frying pan/fire moments with some feminisms ‘cuz they took my fear and loathing of femininity to new heights and depths, but even still, they had a lot to teach me. Luckily, they were also balanced by some of the early third wave publications that assured me that my cleavage was mine and not an evil tool of the patriarchy. As I muddled along learning and integrating and rejecting and reforming, I was also finding my way at last into queer community. At one point, my second girlfriend and I were part of an earnest online discussion about queer gender and butch and femme. I recall saying something to the effect that I wore dresses and boots, checked my own oil, but had someone else change it, so I didn’t know where I fit. My girlfriend laughed and said, “Oh, you’re femme. No doubt about it.”

That was a moment for me. A click. I realized I’d been equating the detested femininity with femme, and they weren’t the same thing. I realized that the trappings of femininity were not the same as the dependence and weakness which were what I really feared and loathed. {Some years later, I’m still working on accepting that dependence and weakness are universal and inescapable aspects of the human experience that need not be permanent or entrapping or defining or even bad.} That same discussion led me to read Stone Butch Blues, and I was impossibly grateful to see working class queer genders reflected and celebrated. Not only was I femme, but femme was rooted in something that looked more like my formative life than anything I’d seen in print up to that point. Yee-haw.

Along comes third girlfriend, a baby butch, and we embarked on our engendering together. We had a commitment ceremony and a house full of cats, and she was the most amazing gentleman butch for me. In those years, I reveled in having a space in my life for those once reviled feminine trappings. Though I still detested pink, I loved purple. Though I still shunned white lace, I couldn’t get enough black lace. Oh, the joys of stockings and garters and corsets and seven different intense shades of lipstick to leave traces of on buttoned-down collars and well-knotted ties. My butch was from a middle class home, so sometimes our ideas of seemliness didn’t quite synch up, but damn, we had some good times learning how to express and perform these parts of ourselves so long stifled and decontextualized.

Which is not to say it was all sunshine and pancakes. I’m not a high femme. In queer community and especially in femme/butch/trans/genderqueer community, high femme is both adored and scorned, but in either case, it is held up as the ultimate expression of femme gender. Did I mention that I’m not a high femme? ‘Cuz I’m not. I wear make-up on special occasions. I avoid pantyhose like the plague. All these years later, I’m still not shaving anything. So, even with purple and black lace and butch in tow, there were spaces I felt unwelcome in, ways I felt my gender expression invalidated and devalued. Those were not good times, and they haven’t left me yet.

Nowadays, my primary partner is a non-trans man, and my femme expression – well, mostly I miss it. Don’t mistake me, I’m still femme. The purple and black lace are still there. I can’t go out of the house without rings and pendants and dangling earbobs, or I’ll feel vaguely naked and uncomfortable through the whole outing. And yet, I am not so flamboyant as I once was. With a butch on my arm, I was obviously queered in a way that made it clear that my purple and black lace were MINE, not the patriarchy’s and certainly not some man’s. With a non-trans man in my vicinity, however conspicuously queer he is, my ownership of myself isn’t so clearly drawn, or at least, it doesn’t feel that way to me.

So, I keep myself to myself that way. Even the most casual observer can see that I don’t fit within the framework of femininity that my heterosexual coworkers occupy. I’m just off somehow, but without a queer context, no one’s sure exactly how. They’re uncomfortable with me, and I’m uncomfortable with them, and that’s that.

Some part of me is always yearning toward a community that will render my gender visible to myself and others again. I have had girlfriends over these last five years, but it’s not the same somehow. After a few attempts at finding some niche of femme/butch/trans/genderqueer community for myself, I’ve pretty much given up. Unwilling to shunt aside the non-trans man I love to fit and unwilling to prioritize shared space in which, as a consequence, my life is not only not reflected but actively dismissed, I’m back where I’ve spent most of my life on just about every identity front – wall walking.

In truth, I’m loathe to admit that my femme self can be so easily obscured and defeated in these ways, but this is the reality of my experience – even here in the queer mecca where I live. Here’s hoping that on some collective level, we’ll realize the sadness, the needlessness of this loss of so many vital queers to our wider LGBTQI community. Here’s hoping femmes can raise our heads and our voices and claim full space for ourselves at last. We are, after all, everywhere.

2 Comments:

Blogger Pagan Topologist said...

Thank you! For this straight white male poly Pagan mathematician, these essays/posts were well worth waiting a year for. It is good to stretch my understanding of people not always like me, and ever since I found your blog linked from Nalo's, I have been drawn to it.

10:36 AM  
Blogger Janine deManda said...

you're welcome! and thanks for your patience and reading. i do most of my blogging on topical sites like antiracistparent and hipmama, so my personal blog gets much less attention, but i'm glad to have a place to put some of my stuff out there, and i'm glad you've found it worth waiting to read.

12:17 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home