Wednesday, October 12, 2005

fodder for Stay Out! Power and Exclusive Spaces

Below are two exchanges between myself and two other posters on a listserv I used to subscribe to, and I thought they would provide good fodder for the essay on exclusive spaces:

An overdue, lengthy, and perhaps overly pedagogic response:

>First of all, this isn't for "whoever identifies as a woman". It's for biological women.

You are, quite simply, wrong. Not for biomen is not the same thing as only for biological women. The Butch/Femme community is perhaps the most trans positive among the panoply of queer communities because we’ve all had shit hurled at us, often by the larger queer community, for our gender expression. I can’t help but notice that you failed to respond to Lani’s assertion of the benefit she gets from women-only and mixed-blood only spaces. Is it so difficult for you to acknowledge that identity spaces you don’t share are valid and integral to those who are part of them? The affirmation available in those spaces is invaluable, as I’m sure you would say yourself about bisexual or sex-positive spaces.

>Second, your use is a reinvention of the word "sexist". Sexism is a descriptive word meaning >"distinction on the basis of sex". Period. You seem to be using it to imply a value judgement, i.e. >"I don't think this is *bad* in any way". We can disagree about the second point -- whether it's >good or bad to segregate men and women -- but not about what "sexist" means.

Again, you are wrong. Limiting the understanding of sexism to “a distinction based on sex” is the work of a conservative judiciary. The definition you mention comes from the line of cases orchestrated by Ruth Bader Ginsburg to create precedent for the legal recognition and alteration of sex discrimination in the law. Justice Ginsburg has a very conservative notion about the breadth and depth of sexism, and that served as the foundation of her arguments. Since she won those cases, it also provides the foundation for sex discrimination law in the U.S. That does not by any means signify that it is the true extent of sexism, or even the entirety of its definition as a term. Most words mean more and different things outside the law than they do in it.

Now, my dictionary was printed in 1971, so it doesn’t include the word sexist. Given that sexism certainly existed in 1971, that omission alone should offer some insight into the fact that the pervasive effects of systems of oppression are easier to sustain when they are unnamed or at least recognized in only minimal ways. However, my dictionary does include a definition of the word racism. In American culture, racism and the struggle against it have provided a template for all other struggles against oppression, so it would be worthwhile to examine that definition. Here it is: Racism: n. 1. a belief that human races have distinctive, inherent characteristics that determine their respective cultures, usually involving the idea that one’s own race is superior and has the RIGHT TO RULE others. 2. a POLICY of ENFORCING such asserted right. 3. a SYSTEM of GOVERNMENT and SOCIETY based upon it. – racist, adj. [emphasis added]

Of course, that definition includes no mention of the construction of Whiteness or global White supremacy, because that would not contribute to their maintenance at all. However, it does discuss the essence of any oppressive system – the POWER with which to ENFORCE it. As any minimal skimming of political theory and its relationship to systems of oppression, whether based on sex, race, class, sexual orientation, gender, color, et cetera, would reveal, police power is the key. When miners struck in the Appalachians, they were not enforcing a classist system by withholding their labor. When the Pinkertons came in and beat and killed them, they were enforcing a classist system with police power. When women or people of color or working class folks or trans folks or BISEXUALS or queers of any stripe gather and create community space, we are RESISTING systems of oppression, not enforcing them. The invitation was for butch and femme identified individuals. Those are gender identities intimately linked to the dyke community. That is a creation of space for butches and femmes that I look forward to savoring. It excludes not just biomen, but any and all folks who don’t embrace those gender identities. There is nothing wrong with that. There is something very, deeply wrong with asserting an entitlement to dictate to a community how and when it can gather, express and affirm itself and the uniquely shared experiences of its members.

>That argument fully justifies excluding bisexuals from gay/lesbian groups.

A point of fact that you and everyone else in this discussion has either been oblivious to or consciously chosen to ignore is that your reasoning would nullify this very chat list and all identity politics. Whether folks who don’t fit the script are overtly included or excluded, identity groups hit all of the {I must say, weak-assed} points on your list of the problematic aspects of a bunch of butches and femmes getting together for a drink at the Bench and Bar. The {ph}allacy of a monolithic human experience supports systems of oppression both implicitly and explicitly. Examples of the way this has and still does play out in people’s everyday lives could and does fill tomes. Here’s one: what do you mean, you can’t work on Saturday? You’re Jewish/Seventh Day Adventist? Too damn bad. The problem is yours, not the system’s. Conform. Be obedient. And don’t ever fucking remind me that you are different or you will be made to suffer further. Progressive social change has ever been a combination of coalition building and the strengthening of community around the particular aspects of identity being punished. A passing familiarity with queer history reveals that the butch/femme community has endured its share of punishment, both from the mainstream and from the mainstream queer community. Taking space to affirm ourselves and each other is not mutually exclusive with continuing to be contributors to other, larger communities, movements, and identities.

>You're saying, "I have a clear understanding, and you don't." That's just ad hominem.

Actually, I would assert that it's a rather gentle assertion of observable fact based on your own writings.

>Well, you're not hearing me say that. It's a question of access. I've never seen a Kwanzaa or >Black History Month event that was racially segregationist.

That was offered as a parallel. You are saying that when you question the right of any identity group you are not a part of to create space for itself. Further, let’s clarify our terms. The word segregation has a very clear history in the U.S., and nowhere in that long and painful struggle has there ever been a space in which Black people could segregate White people: Segregate: v. 1. to separate or set apart from others or remove from the main body or group. 2. to require, often with FORCE, the separation of a specific racial, religious, or other group from the general body of society. 3. to practice, require, or ENFORCE segregation, especially racial segregation. [emphasis added]

>A-ha, thoughtcrime!

Convenient, isn’t it, to dismiss critiques of one’s own participation, conscious or not, in systems of oppression as oppressive. A nice diversionary tactic, nearly perfected, I would say, by the right wing in American politics. Of course, if one is committed to dealing with one’s own complicity with oppression and to continuing to grow and learn to contribute to a world where such archaic torture devices may one day wither away and die like Marx’s nation state, then one doesn’t want to just sidestep the issue. One wants to engage it. Somehow, I’m guessing, you’d be peeved if a monosexual dismissed your criticism of their biphobia as thoughtpolicing and left it at that.


>I don't think anyone here would argue what that history, and current practice, is on the side of >men. That makes unilateral sexism understandable, but not good. The reaction to that history >attempts to create a "separate but equal" world -- a concept that's antihumanist, not to >mention unamerican <http://64.4.26.250/cgi-bin/linkrd?_lang=EN&lah=287f01383575e520a169d72af92cbd7f&lat=1078094721&hm___action=http%3a%2f%2fwww%2elaw%2eumkc%2eedu%2ffaculty%2fprojects%2fftrials%2fconlaw%2fsepbutequal%2ehtm>.)

Again, you are just flat wrong. Community spaces created around oppressed identities are not, as everyone should well know, attempts to create a separate but equal world. They are attempts to provide spaces of safety where individuals with shared experiences of oppression can find strength and support for their continued engagement with systems of oppression. If you are a butch dyke, going to the Bench and Bar isn’t going to make sexism and homophobia and gender policing go away outside, and you know it. You’re just seeking some solace to enable you to continue to engage with that daily reality because you have NO CHOICE but to engage with it unless you want to retreat to a hermitage or off yourself. Alternatively, men don't have to engage sexism, or cisgendered folks gender policing, or straights heterosexism and homophobia unless they CHOOSE to do so because those oppressive systems favor them instead of punishing them.

Again, the POWER to ENFORCE a separate but equal world is not in the hands of oppressed people. When every place else belongs to those who do hold that power, it helps to have some shelter from it in order to continue working to change it. If humanism fails to address the very real disparities among humans and proposes that if we just all hang out together everything will be hunky dory, it is baldly oblivious to millennia of human history and the reality of human life in the present day.

As for the link, it doesn’t support your argument. Plessy v. Ferguson was a case created for the sole purpose of challenging segregation, and it failed. The plaintiff, a man who was of one sixty-fourth Black descent and who looked for all the world like a White man, was told by those with the POWER to ENFORCE their will where he could sit on the train. That was that for a damn long time. When Thurgood Marshall succeeded in challenging that atrocious policy and history in the courts, he was enabled by a community and education rich with the strength and support provided in spaces made safe by the presence of positive Black identity politics.

UnAmerican? Oh, please.

>If you say Sexism (or racism, classism, etc.) is O.K. for the historically oppressed, you get a >society based on revenge. Or outright atrocities.

Bullshit. If a feminist consciousness raising group limits participation to women, neither revenge nor atrocity is involved. If a Black student group prefers not to admit members of the Klan, neither revenge nor atrocity is involved. If one day, the film White Man’s Burden is reality instead of simply Planet of the Apes-style hysteria, then there will be some basis for your argument. In the meantime, the argument remains paranoid and lazy. The vast majority of identity communities are creating space with hopes of healing and protecting themselves {and maybe even contributing to a world that really is actually just for all}, and not with aspirations of being the basis for the future governing system of oppression on par with Imperialist Global White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy.

>But black racism and female sexism is wrong as well. It deserves attention proportional to the >damage it does -- an amount I'd say is substantial.

Black racism and female sexism are oxymorons. Black only, Native only, Jewish only, Women only spaces are not harming anyone. Period. If someone gets their feelings hurt because suddenly they have to face that the whole world isn’t accessible on their entitled whim, then that’s their individual work to do. The Guerilla Girls have a poster that says, “Q: If February is Black History Month, and March is Women’s History Month, what happens the rest of the year? A: Discrimination.” It’s like self-righteous individuals challenging my Women’s Studies minor with the inane question, “Why isn’t there a Men’s Studies minor?” The answer, of course, is that is what constitutes the rest of the curriculum. Parity is sought. Balance. 5000 years of patriarchy are not undone yet. Far from it. Cry foul when balance has become overcompensation, not before. You’ll have, without any doubt, a damn long wait.

>Ooo, I've always hated those terms, and would never use them. It's sexism and racism, period.

Yes, it is. Racism is about the oppression of People of Color by White people. Sexism is about the oppression of Women by Men.

>Don't you put words in my mouth.

Again, you sidestepped the issue. As a man in patriarchy, you are a person in a position of power. Your entitlement has been affirmed in countless explicit and implicit ways for the entirety of your life. Though it is contingent on your obedience to certain normative masculinities, it promises you possession of women’s bodies, which, as chattel, form the basis of patriarchy, however far we’ve moved away from overtly acknowledging that in modern Western culture. If women can take there bodies into the Bench and Bar one Thursday evening and tell you that you can’t come in, you have been deprived of access, of your entitlement. You are irked.

>Or we could simply disagree. At least I'm not calling you names, saying your thoughts are bad, >or accusing you of stupidity in doing so.

You weren’t? ‘Cuz as a femme woman, I gotta say that your {admittedly specious} arguments felt rife with accusations and value judgments to me. So, you can disagree by expressing your opinion in this forum, but others should just shrug it off and agree to disagree without asserting their position, experience, or perspective? In all honesty, I thought the responses to your initial list of objections was stunningly civil, restrained, and mild mannered, from one and all. Your position so reeked of entitlement and unquestioned privilege that I felt the need to take a day to calm the rage it inspired in me before drafting a response. Saying something inflammatory and then expecting that no one will be enflamed is just poor logic. Even with your skewed perspective on the realities of sexism and life in patriarchy, you must have recognized the offensive politic your words align you with.

>That sums up my feelings perfectly.

Clearly, it does not. If you would prefer to celebrate diversity rather than stifle it, you wouldn’t object to individuals with shared experiences utterly different from your own getting together with each other. You would understand that they are still and inevitably tangled in the human experience, and you would know that if and when your paths crossed, you might be more apt to learn from them and they from you because they had safe space in which to recover from and prepare for a world in which people who look like you fuck shit up for people who look like them every day. When I moved here last year, I had hoped to find a community in which I could rest after the three years of daily political debate about my very right to exist that constituted my legal education experience. Much to my joy, I have found those places of respite here and there. Much to my dismay, I still encounter those debates, find them insinuating themselves into spaces I thought were safe. It keeps me sharp, but sometimes it can be much more exhausting and disheartening than 500 Midwestern republicans.
With all due respect,
Janine

start second exchange:

hello, all, i'm not sure if melissa said it on this list or another one, but she mentioned being overwhelmed by all the thoughts and things flying around, and i can completely relate to that. there has been much said here and elsewhere that has had me talking to myself and others at some length. time and my own inarticulateness has delayed me writing most of it out. some of these are concepts i want to wrestle into some semblance of clarity before attempting to express in a forum. however, there were some things [previous poster] said that i felt able to speak to more readily.


>I wonder... I wonder what it's like to be a man. I wonder what it's like to have a good job and >make enough money. I wonder what it's like to be black, a black man, in my neighborhood. I >wonder what's like to be looked at as though you have that much power.

now, a couple of things leapt out at me here. first, none of the men i grew up knowing had good jobs or enough money. class is an all too frequently ignored differentiator of experience. i do not suggest that poor and working poor men don't enjoy some benefits of maleness in a sexist, patriarchal society, but i would argue with the presupposition that sex is the only or the biggest obstacle to financial independence and economic power. second, what power? the power of racist mythologies of black maleness? {the thing that always got me about them is that they're the exact same mythologies that have been applied to jewish, native, &/or poor maleness and are also often applied generically to queerness. seriously, check out some of the old broadsheets about the ravening jew's threat to good, christian womanhood, et cetera.} or merely the power of being male in patriarchy? if the latter, then why the modifier?


>My power comes from me. My place as a mom, as a woman, as a strong, smart person. In my >way, in my home, with my son, at sex parties, in women's space, in my community(s) of >choice, I feel powerful.

right on. the disparity between spaces in which a person feels able to relax and spaces in which a person feels the need to be on guard can be startling. i remember my aunt feeling pretty bleak when she left the michigan festival and realized the gulf between how much latitude she felt willing to allow my cousin in that space which she largely trusted and that which she allowed her everywhere else. still, that in itself speaks to the importance of those spaces.


>I feel helpless in my physical community. I think that [a previous poster] and I live in the same >building and when I saw what he said about his neighborhood it floored me. I'm so scared here, >outside my building, all the time.

actually, this floored me. i live in that building, too, and i have a completely different relationship to my neighborhood. perhaps this is qualified by the fact that i am pretty much constantly on guard in certain senses whenever i am navigating the world of men regardless of whether i'm in the city or the country, in oakland or sf. in point of fact, my tension _increases_ relative to signifiers apparently nearly polar opposites to those [you] mentioned.
just the other day, i was standing at a bus stop, and it wasn't until i got on the bus and relaxed that i realized how tense i had been. the source of my tension was a long-haired, scraggly bearded white man in denim and flannel, and behind him, years of experiencing violence from very like forms. in that moment, as in other, similar moments, i questioned my reactivity. being on guard is one thing, but accepting a habit of pathologizing whole groups of people based on limited personal experience feels, well, wrong to me.
of course, for my entire adult life, i have been conscious of being more frightened as a woman of white men with class privilege than of any other general category of men because i'm clear, from history and experience, how easily they can get away with brutal shit while men who are poor &/or of color are far more apt to be punished or at least to expect punishment. so, how's that for the pot?
thinking about all of this, though, i realize that most of the _actually threatened_ spaces i have been in as an adult have been largely rooted in my queerness, not only in my womanhood. i know i relate to all of this in my own ways, but in any case, i like my neighborhood. i feel at ease there in ways i don't in sf. though i have been harassed by faux freaks and tourists in sf, i have not had that experience in my neighborhood. i'm not saying crime doesn't happen in my neighborhood. i'm just saying i remain unconvinced on a gut level that it's more likely to happen there or will by definition be more violent.

>And honestly, having to not fear men, not fear the power that we seem to see them holding >over us all the time, gives me the space and energy to go out again and fight the good fight and >stand with the men in my life who are not violent, who I can trust and who create other forms >of safe space. Without my safe space I can't be in other spaces effectively. This, for me, is not an >academic argument. This is about how *I* feel and how I can live my life safely.

yes, i concur. this is exactly what creating exclusive space for oppressed folks is about, whether that healing and renewal is done in a CR group or over a drink and a game of pool.
for now,
janine

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home