Saturday, December 03, 2005

Same Sex Marriage and Redefinition of the Family

{very rough draft written roughly two years ago}

My mother was married once - to my father. They were legally joined eight and a half months before I was born, and they were legally sundered eleven years later. For the last seven years of their legal marriage, they lived in different states, spoke very rarely, and saw each other in person on two occasions, the second of which was when they appeared in divorce court.

What my mother learned from this was that love and commitment have nothing to do with legal documents or the imprimatur of the state. She turned down more than one marriage proposal after learning that, including more than one from the man I think of as my stepfather. Her rejection of the institution of marriarge did not prevent her from experiencing the burdens and rewards of a long term relationship. She has been doing just that with my stepfather-type-person for over twenty years now.

Although she attempted to convey this lesson to me when I was growing up and despite my own belief that I'd learned it, I was legally married briefly in my early twenties. That is, I think, attributable to the same social pressures, inculcation, and expectations that lead me to celebrate an outlaw marriage {a.k.a. commitment ceremony} with my then-girlfriend in my mid-twenties. We're all familiar with the inundation of messages about marriage that we receive from toddlerhood to dotage.

As a response to that inundation, as an assertion of full civil personhood Loving v. Virginia style, I understand the push for same-sex marriage. As an ultimate political or personal goal, as the litmus test for a society that honors all families and all committed relationships, I don't. In the former cases, it's a simple, gut-level desire for equality. In the latter, it's a short sighted, unimaginative, bad bargain that sells a lot of us not just short, but completely out.

Although my parents' marriage did not serve the socially approved purpose of providing a stable resource base for the cooperative rearing of a child, the network of friendships my mother developed with other women did just that, though of course, absent the societal approval. As an adult, I have been part of such networks, much to my benefit and edification. Yes, as a poly queer in a web of relationships, I am excluded from the welcome-to-the-mainstream party same-sex marriage proponents have been throwing for themselves lately, but frankly, that doesn't really distress me. Not only do I not want to marry my primary or secondary partners {in no small part because I've been there and don't feel the need to return to the land of patriarchal institutions {and their knock-offs } rooted in misogyny, sexism, and women-as-chattel}, but I don't think it would make it all better if I could.

We don't need a government that outlaws love and expects us to obey such laws. We don't need a society that grudgingly tolerates the reality of love's variety and complexity. We don't need a country in which a person's access to certain necessities like healthcare and certain benefits like cheaper car insurance are conditioned on that person's obedience to archaic institutional norms. What we need is government that keeps its nose out of the regulation of family structures. What we need is a society that respects every adult's right to create the relationships that suit them best. What we need is a country in which a person has access to necessities simply because they are necessary and to benefits because they are warranted under individually-based, objective {so much as that's possible} standards.

As usual, my mother was right. If love is going to stay, love is going to stay. If love is going to go, love is going to go. A piece of paper from the government has squat to do with that. So, let's stop squabbling about scraps of dead tree flesh and start working and respecting together to help love be.

{brief addendum written right now}

Okay, and I get that there's more to the pursuit of legal marriage than an equality-gut thing. Loving v. Virginia didn't just give equal recognition to marriages between white and non-white people, it also gave important protections to those people and their children. That's nothing to scoff at. Yes, in my humble opinion, we should be working toward a complete overhaul of society's relationship to families in their fabulous variety. In the meantime, though, I totally get that the protections afforded by legal marriage are desperately needed by queer families, especially working class queer families. If you can get legally married, then maybe a homophobic judge will be unable to get past that substantial obstacle to giving custody of your kids to your whack ex-gay sperm donor. {I knew someone who actually lost her children to the man who donated sperm for them back before his fundie family brought him back to jesus from queerness. As a mother, I can hardly fathom the soul-deep pain she lives with everyday.} If you can get legally married, then you can both have healthcare even if only one of you has a job that includes coverage.

The list goes on, and yes, some of the things on that list {tax breaks} sound like the concern only of people with enough economic privilege to hire an attorney and an accountant and get them some other way. Some of them, though, cut extremely close to the specific bones of poor and working class queers who may not have representation on HRC's board, but would nonetheless benefit directly from the accomplishment of this goal. I totally get that. I just also get a lot that HRC and many same-sex marriage proponents seem to be willfully not getting. I just wish that folks would stop promising to sell out the sluts and trannies and freaks for a place at that double-damned table when there's so much more we could accomplish if we just marched right on in the kitchen and started cooking our own meals.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home