Wednesday, October 12, 2005

Mischling, Second Degree[1]: Mixed Blood Identity and Race Politics

Mischling, Second Degree[1]: Mixed Blood Identity and Race Politics
By Janine M. deManda
I hate white people! I hate the white part of myself! I keened through tears, seven years old in my grandma's kitchen. She tried to soothe me, but she could not. Even today, though I am grateful for the affirmation found in conversation and in the writings of others with similarly complex heritages, nothing soothes. That is for the best, I think.
In a world implicitly and explicitly governed in large part by the fiction of race and the harsh realities that fiction engenders, I would not want to be soothed out of the dysphoric tension born in me that day and into complacency and complicity with white supremacist politics. People like me are, I would assert, terribly distressing to the maintenance of that politic. We fit neatly nowhere, and so our very existence challenges the veracity of race-based dichotomies and easy platitudes about inherent natures.
One solution to the mixed blood problem has been returned to over and over – prevent or erase our existence, at least in the eyes of the law. From anti-miscegenation laws to the one-drop rule to the whitefying policies enforced on mixed bloods in Australia[2] and thoughtfully considered in the United States,[3] the institutions of the state have been dead set against us for a long time now. That vehement opposition is almost entirely due to the aforementioned politics our existences belie. On both individual and institutional levels, racism is made less tenable if the intended object has a face that looks remarkably like that of the intended subject, but of course, it is in no way brought up short by this complication.
What made me keen so that day in my grandma's kitchen was the blood she gave me, both in word and body. I had come home from school with social studies homework about the "way the west was won." The pages of the textbook were slick, white, and entirely free of bloodstains. Their pristine quality was entirely due to the fact that they had been stripped of huge portions of truth, my grandma let me know. She told me about small pox blankets, massacres, reservation starvations, forced relocations, land thefts. She played Johnny Cash's "the Ballad of Ira Hayes."
Up until then, I hadn't really thought about my heritage in terms of historical dispossession, genocide, and conflict. Up until then, I'd just listened to my grandma's stories of how her Grandma Cora was Blackfoot but raised by Gypsies, of how her Grandpa Joe was Blackfoot and came to Missouri to work in the coal mines, of how her Grandma Laura's folks had left the Cherokee reservation in Oklahoma looking for a decent living. I'd heard her tell of Grandma Laura's river of hair, Grandma Cora's chewin' tobacco habit, and Grandpa Joe's long suffering patience with Cora's gallivantin' ways. Years later, I'd learn how my father's mother, half Irish and half Onondaga, had left the town on the edge of the Onondaga reservation to pass into whiteness, of how she took her children to visit her mother's sisters on reservation and then firmly tutored them in their whiteness on the drive home. Years later, I learned a lot of things, but until that day, all I'd learned was family. On that day, I was learning about race, society, and the evils that can be wreaked by the latter in the name of the former. I have never forgotten what I learned.
That day's lesson was with me when I sat in World History class in high school and completely failed to listen to the assistant football coach lecture on World War II. I was transfixed by the tiny photograph in the half page inset that was all the textbook gave to the Holocaust. {The inset was not white. It was brown. Perhaps that was why the fragmentary summary of genocide stuck there and failed to adhere to the rest of the pale, glossy pages.} The photograph was of one desiccated corpse, stiff on the frozen ground of a liberated concentration camp. I can't recall which one it was. For the first time in my life, I felt faint. My head spun, and my stomach lurched, and I stared at that photograph.
Before that photograph, the Holocaust was something that had caused my Uncle Al's tattoo, but it was not something discussed in any depth. Anti-Semitism was something I was conscious of, but I'm not sure I knew the word then. I knew Uncle Al had lost his entire family. I knew that he came to the United States alone and married my Aunt Miriam, my grandfather's sister. I knew that my grandfather's mother emigrated from Russia at age thirteen, sent West with her elder brother to escape the pogroms. I knew that my grandfather's orthodox family was horrified when he married a gentile, a goy, and that my grandmother's family wasn't thrilled that she'd married a Jew. Again, I knew family stories. Again, as I stared at that photograph, devoured that inset's modest text, I was learning about race, society, and the evils committed by the latter in the name of the former.
What both of those days and all of those stories communicated to me was the unalterable fact of my otherness, my lack of security in a world where any who fail to exist within the parameters of whiteness can, at any given moment, fall victim to that construction's need for an Other. The incongruity between my light complexion and my racial otherness has been the source of some distress for me and for just about everyone else who in anyway engages it. The fact that I live in a world that strives every day to persuade me to identify as and with whiteness in no way lessens that distress.
Those strivings have proven ultimately unpersuasive in part because they mirror similar attempts to deproblematize my class, my gender, my sexuality. In each of those contexts, I have astounding clarity about the precariousness of my acceptance, of the constant imminence of my return to exile. Say the wrong thing, do the wrong thing, deviate in any way from the prescribed norms for straight, white, middle class, appropriately feminine women, and you will be punished. Thanks to my ma's lessons in personhood, I've never gone in for dissembling to increase the comfort of others. In addition to which, I completely lack the patience for life on a tightrope someone else could cut at any moment. Oh, and then of course, there's my outrage and irritation at norms that insist on excluding me, pretty much everyone I love, and contribute to the overall fucked-upness of the world in a huge way. So, I speak my peace at just about every opportunity. It makes a lot of folks uncomfortable, maybe it even provokes some to critical thought. It makes walking this particular wall a bit more bearable, and that helps. It does.
The thing is, though, nothing soothes. Even still, nothing soothes, and that is for the best, I think. That is for the best.
[1] Mischling, second degree is what I would be classified as under the race laws of the Third Reich. Mischling roughly translates as mixed or mongrel, and the second degree indicates two degrees of remove from full-blood Jewishness – one Jewish grandparent.
[2] These policies provide the context for the movie "Rabbit Proof Fence", based on the lived experience of a mixed blood girl's resistance to assimilation. The scene in which the policy for the erasure of mixed bloods is explained brought me to tears in the theater because that policy was law for nearly a century.
[3] When Nickels Were Indians: An Urban Mixed-Blood Story by Patricia Penn Hilden includes an excerpt from the writings of a scholar noted for his study of the Iroquois {the Haudenosaunee, the confederacy of which the Onondaga is one nation} in which he details his consideration and rejection of miscegenation to the point of erasure as a solution to the Indian problem. According to this fellow, it was the lasciviousness of quarterbloods like myself that threw a wrench in the works.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home