Monday, May 19, 2008

The Margins Are Our Center

The Margins Are Our Center
by Janine M. deManda

My daughter will is fast approaching her fourth birthday. She is a joyous being, and that’s not just an indulgent mama talking. Folks remark on it all the time. Unsurprisingly, I’m fiercely protective of her and her joy. Uncomfortably, I’m aware that my very way of being in the world is likely to cause my daughter pain, to dampen her joy. I don’t look forward to that dampening, but in hopes of minimizing it, I’m working to create a family context that is affirming and safe and loving and as complicated as we are all wont to be.

My daughter is the child of a white-skinned, jewfroed, mixed blood, mischling, escaped working poor, fat, poly, femme dyke, queer feminist from the country with a chronic illness and a law degree. My daughter is the child of a phenotypically African-American, locks down to his waist, solidly middle class, short, thick, poly, butchqueen fag, anti-sexist, queer geek from Chicago with an MFA. My daughter is beloved of an extended family of affinity that includes genderqueer urbanites and wise country-dwellers, that is rich with aunts and cousins and possibilities. She has blood kin across the country and around the world, and some of ‘em get it, and some of ‘em don’t. My daughter has a queer family that just about everyone, queer and not, are all too eager to perceive through a heteronormative lens.

Navigating all this is just the complicated icing on the bittersweet cake of being her mama, and I’d like to share a slice of our realities in this essay. Here’s the thing, though – I’m stuck. Over the last several weeks, I have made several abortive attempts to write this essay. When I sit down and try to think of how to talk about our lives, I’m overwhelmed and at a loss.
See, on the one hand, we can be seen as assimilable – just your average, two biological parents, opposite sex, registered with the government, middle income family of three. On the other hand, we are forever moving through the misty grey areas at intersections of identity – just your average, two queer parents, genderqueered, domestic partnered, cross-class family of three. On still another hand, we are choosing every day to maintain our marginality by refusing to pass as either a heterosexual or a homosexual family. Both parents are fiercely queer identified, polyamorous, anti-racist, anti-sexist, and anti-classist people who insist on asking uncomfortable questions of ourselves, our contexts, our world. And that’s not even the whole of it.

When I was a kid, sometimes my Ma would sit me down after a particular struggle we had about something and explain to me that she hadn’t taken the position she had taken just to make me insane. {Surprised? I was.} She was trying to give me the tools she felt I most needed to take care of myself in life and find happiness – independence, compassion, critical thinking skills, and strength of will. At the time, I was awed not only by her vision in looking so far beyond the present moment that had so completely absorbed my attention, but by the her capacity to maintain her focus on those goals on a daily basis and in the midst of the minutiae of our daily lives. Now that I’m a mama myself, I’m still awed {and also inspired}, but I understand in a way I couldn’t before how compelled we can feel as parents to keep our eyes on the prize of our children’s adulthoods.

With that in mind, I can see beyond a childhood and adolescence in which my daughter may be mortified by my vocalness as a queer, polyamorous, mixed blood, escaped working class, fat, gimp femme to an adulthood in which her experience of that may have equipped her with perspectives and tools - like those her grandmother gave me – that will best enable her own autonomy and happiness. Of course, sometimes I’m terrified that she will instead feel herself so traumatized by her parents’ freakishness that she’ll tamp herself down to fit as best she can within the available boxes in order to avoid any further time spent walking the walls between identities where we live.

Though I have been loathe all of my life to let fear limit or dictate my choices, I have made an exception with regard to that second possible future. I am going to do everything in my power to provide my daughter a context for her family that renders us just one more possibility on a broad spectrum of possibilities. I am not doing this because I think normal – whatever the hell that would mean for us – is an ideal. I am doing this because I think that broad spectrum is an ideal. I am doing this because I think giving my daughter that spectrum, regardless of where she finds herself on it later in life, is right up there with independence, compassion, critical thinking skills, and strength of will on the list of useful tools. I am doing this because I believe that in order to be a good parent, I need to do essentially the same things I need to do to be a good human, and high on that list is to be honest, to be true to myself, to try to create a world I want to live in and pass on.

So, we live in the San Francisco Bay area. That gives us a serious leg up in the spectrum category ‘cuz here we are far from the only whatever we are – lots of mixed race families, lots of mixed class families, lots of LGBTIQ families {some of which are even also “opposite” sex}, lots of families that take politics very personally, lots of families in which one or more parent may occasionally dress all in black leather. Hell, there are even other families here with polyamorous parents. We are not alone around our centralized margin campfire, no, ma’am.

In addition, we head back to the Midwest at least once a year to visit kin, blood and affinity {we also welcome them into our home as often as we can pry them out of the prairie}. That gives us a serious leg up in the spectrum category, too, ‘cuz there we have folks who give us home, who give us love, who let us know that we are always welcome, and who remind us that not all the freaks and thinkers have fled to the coastal cities. In the broad, rolling hills my daughter has called an ocean since first seeing them, we have a connection to the cycling natural world often missing from our daily lives in the city, and we have folks who are keeping a place for us. No, ma’am, we are not alone around that centralized margin campfire back in the heartland either.

Didn’t someone once say that it takes a village to raise a child? Yeah? Well, we are doing our incremental damnedest to cobble one together for this joyous being that gives her family room to be and shares some fields and houses and pathways with other kids’ villages, too.
In truth, I’m not sure I’ve quite done what I set out to do here. I didn’t really talk about the special marginalization bisexuals and polyamorists can feel within the larger queer community. I didn’t really delve into what it means to me to be an out queer parent whose queerness is elided every day by the assumptions of others or the awkward privilege of passing that can impose. I didn’t do a lot of the things I thought I had to do when I was feeling overwhelmed about writing this essay, but I hope I did do something like open a window, however narrow, onto the world of this particular queer family. I hope there’s a cool little zephyr coming through that window carrying sweet and spiced scents which entices ya’ll to climb on through and join us around that campfire – or at least tell your friends and your kids that it’s a lovely view worth checking out sometime.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home