Wednesday, October 12, 2005

Backstory: a Very Shorthand History of the Creation of Racist Consciousness

Backstory on Backstory: The introduction to an anthology of feminist essays slapped me in the face with a story about how the editor and the women of color students in a women's studies class she was teaching chastised the Jewish women students in the class into silence when the latter asserted that their experience of Otherness closely paralleled that of women of color. It wasn't the first time I had come up against that knot of issues, but it jarred me. This essay came out of my hurt and anger, and it's a bit more of a rant than the other drafts here. It communicates something I want to communicate, but I think it needs more work to do so more coherently.

{Yes, I know I made some inaccurate overgeneralizations about the history of the Scottish/English conflict. Anyone got the correct dates for me?}

Backstory: a Very Shorthand History of the Creation of Racist Consciousness

I'm angry. For those who know me, this isn't a new or rare thing, but for them and for those of you just meeting me in this book, I do want to explain this specific rage. Perhaps in the course of doing so, I can decrease the causes of it even just a little. Even a little would help.
Okay, so pretty much anyone even half awake in the world today will admit, though some of them may do so very grudgingly, that racism, imperialism, and that big umbrella, global white supremacy, are kinda problematic. Unfortunately, some of the most articulate, astute, with-it folks who will grant you that have only the most rudimentary, essentialist understanding of race. This is where this specific aspect of my anger comes in because my personal relationship to race is on the convoluted side.
Okay, so let's start at the beginning. Race is a social construct. Let's repeat that again with feeling: RACE IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCT. I don't give a good goddamn what some heavily invested scientists have said over the centuries. Since when was science the unbiased bastion of truth anyway? Beyond a shadow of any kind of skinny-assed doubt, people got together and made this shit up awhile back, and just about everyone since has been collaborating with them in one way or another. Now, I realize that's a rather vague summary, so let me clarify it a bit.
Some time back, some gangs of Germans and Danes – back then they were known as Angles, Saxons, and Jutes – were rampaging all over Europe {which is fucking well just northwestern Asia, okay. Shit.}. They were having a merry old time killing Celts and Picts and Britons {though they didn't fuck much with the Scots until some centuries later}, stealing their shit, and generally taking over their land, lives, and cultures. Sound familiar?
Okay, so some time passes, and a lot of those marauders have settled down to nice quiet lives in Albion, better known to us today as England. Along came the Romans and gave them basically the same treatment {though they, too, didn't fuck much with the Scots}. Happily for the new English, the Romans didn't like the weather much and went home. Unhappily for the rest of the planet and centuries of history right on down to us, they left behind notions about globe-spanning empires and the superiority of the imperial culture.
So, the English eventually decided to try their hand at this whole conquer and assimilate thing. The closest folk who weren't the Scots were the Welsh, lucky them. The English made their way through Wales, killing people and building castles. The killing was to subdue the spirit of the native people, and the castles were to garrison troops who could do more subduing if anyone got the clever idea of challenging the English theft of their lands. That done, the English decided to add their own personal flair to the Roman blueprint for empire. They outlawed the native language and the native religion of the native people. Now, I know this is sounding familiar.
Given their fairly solid success over the Welsh, the English decided to go after the Irish next {still avoiding the Scots, see – better to get in a boat and sail to Ireland than to ride north and face the Clans.}. Using the same implements of cultural and spiritual destruction, the English put a chokehold on the Irish right up to the last century, and perhaps to this very day depending on your perspective. Then came the French to try and reshape the nascent English empire, but they just weren't nearly bloody-minded enough, and eventually, the English had things back in their own hands.
While the English were busily inventing Whiteness/Otherness, they, along with all of Christian Europe, had the template for it before them everyday. Much as Wales and Ireland provided laboratories for invasion and subjugation strategies, so European Jews were the original test subjects for the daily implementation of ghettoization, scapegoating, and periodic, random violent retributions for the crime of being the wrong race. Before science got in on the game and contributed its objective knowledge to the justification of genocide, slavery, and imperialism, granddaddy religion was on the scene to give a big thumbs up to the periodic slaughter of pogroms and the daily dehumanizations of ghettos and special demarcations. {Now see, this is part of what gets me. Folks – Jewish and non – insisting that Jews are White because many of us are lately of European descent and therefore bear a passing resemblance to your average WASP. For centuries before the Third Reich instituted forced concentrations of Jews and the required wearing of the Star of David to insure that everyone was clear about who was the wrong race, just about every European city had a Jewish ghetto where Jews were required by law to live and some specific dress code that required Jews by law to distinguish themselves from non-Jews with a certain kind of hat or the like. Remember the first lesson, class? Say it with me: RACE IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCT. Jews were the first construction site. Trust.}
Now, the English, being the English, went right to the head of the class with anti-Semitism. They just flat evicted Jews en masse from their sweet little seat of empire. Along with the rest of Christian {read White} Europe, the English cited the Jews for having a list of characteristics that should be familiar to every group ever classified as Other: barbaric, deceitful, inhuman, lascivious, and of course, a danger to the children of real people. The English were priming themselves for the coming of Victoria, and when their chance came, they were ready. After Christopher Columbus was so kind as to discover the new world, the English leapt at the chance to expand their Empire. In fairly short order, they had most of the planet in the same chokehold they had the Irish, and they had most of the other European nations miming their pattern.
Now some of ya'll might argue at this point that I'm confusing ethnicity and race. I'm not, and here's why. First, though you may be getting a bit tired of it by now, it bears repeating: RACE IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCT. So, the only thing differentiating race and ethnicity is the religious opinion, pseudo-science, and general attitudes of White people. In short, the whim of the powers that be. That's why the best survival strategy for anyone who has been or could be again on the wrong side of the governing definition of race is to be very clear about our non-whiteness and disregard any of the lying promises of assimilation. Most Jews born in Germany in 1937 had a J marked on their birth certificates in the race box. Most Jews born in the United States in 2004 have a W marked on their birth certificates in the race box. None of them were or are safe from being marked for death by an anti-Semite. That's the bottom line.
Now, I appreciate that some folks have had what appears to be the way cleared for them in the United States, but I assure you, it's still all a matter of whim. Each wave of immigrants to this country, contrary to what Ms. Liberty's book says, have been ferociously resisted by all preceding waves, voluntary or not. When the Irish flooded in as a result of the potato famine {not an actual famine, by the way, just the all too familiar scenario in which the people who already have take everything from those who don't in the name of good business}, they were vehemently non-White. Nowadays, most of them would vehemently claim Whiteness. The same goes for Italian-Americans, Polish-Americans, and so on. You might be saying, well, but they are White. The thing is, though, they're not. How many times have you heard jokes involving the Irish, Italians, Poles, et cetera, as general, monolithic peoples? More than that, have you heard dirty mick? Fuckin' deigo? Stupid polack? Now, think a minute, how often have you heard similar jokes about the English? Danes? the Dutch? Does the average American even know an epithet specifically referring to the English?
Light skin comes into this debate, too. Most Irish have it; many Italians don't, but most Americans would claim both are White. Of course, many folks from Central and South America have pale skin, pale eyes, pale hair, and very minimal chances of being assimilated into Whiteness. Why? Because they are part of the most recent and therefore the most vehemently opposed wave of immigrants. At the same time, those scientists I mentioned earlier keep insisting that race is biologically essential and that folks from the Middle East are part of the White race. Really? I don't know about you, but I'd be willing to bet that there are a number of Americans with dark skin, dark eyes, and dark hair whose parents or grandparents emigrated to the U.S. from Syria or Lebanon or Egypt who would vehemently disagree with that premise based on their personal and familial experiences of racism in America.
So, is this making some sense now? Race is a social construct, and it's been constructed in all kinds of ways all over the goddamn place for a long ass time. So, could ya'll please stop working on essentialist assumptions and telling me and people like me {perhaps including yourself} that we're White? Could you give some thought to the spectrum of race? To the range of White, Off-White, Non-White, and Of Color? 'Cuz I for one would sure as hell appreciate it. Not to mention that we could get a lot more accomplished if we were working to build coalitions instead of working to maintain myths of purity. Shit.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home