I Would Prefer To: Reproductive Rights Aren’t Just About Not Reproducing
{Extremely rough draft written in stolen moments in the midst of my work day.}
When I was a teenager, Planned Parenthood sent a medical professional to my backwater county once a month. She set up shop in a local doctor's office and offered gynecological and contraceptive health care to young women who otherwise wouldn't have had any. Although I became sexually active before going to that monthly clinic, I did go and get on the pill. For years afterward, I felt I owed a great debt to Planned Parenthood for saving me from coping with an unplanned pregnancy and possibly motherhood while I was still in my teens. When I went away to college, I was completely alienated by the student health center, and a similarly alienated fellow student referred me to the local Planned Parenthood office. The nurse practitioner there had a good sense of humor, a gentle, competent hand, and a true gift for the healing arts. She was a woman comfortable in her lesbianism, and coming out to her and talking with her helped me become comfortable with my own queerness. I felt my debt to Planned Parenthood had grown.
A few years later, I moved to Kansas City, and thanks to that same nurse practitioner {hurray for the old dykes' network}, I got a job answering phones at the KC Planned Parenthood. In the way of non-profits, willing hands were put to work in a variety of ways, and I ended up being trained to work as an abortion counselor. The two years I spent helping women through the often difficult and challenging experience of ending a pregnancy taught me a great many things, not the least of which was the incredible importance of women's reproductive freedom of choice. While there, I saw women who had been anti-choice come to new realizations about these complex issues when their own circumstances brought them to choose abortion, and I saw women who remained vehemently anti-choice even as they had abortions themselves. While there, I learned about risking violence to provide care, and I learned that the care we provided was only an aspect of women's reproductive freedom of choice.
Unfortunately, reproductive freedom activism and activist organizations are often so besieged by anti-choice fanaticism that they lose sight of all the other aspects. They see access to abortion as a crisis, and the rest falls by the wayside. That is a very dangerous approach. The assumptions that underlie anti-choice rhetoric are the same as those that underlie involuntary sterilization and other punitive measures against mothers who dare to be poor and/or non-white. Fighting for abortion access is important, but if the fight is limited to that, it is doomed to fail. Reproductive freedom has to be fought for in all its aspects, and those underlying assumptions have to be challenged: Women's bodies are our own, not mere tools for the reproductive use of men. Motherhood should be supported by society. Poverty should be ameliorated, not criminalized. All children should be valued and provided access to necessities and resources.
Most of the mothers and their children I know wouldn't qualify for existence as such based on those underlying assumptions. We are poor and/or non-white and/or unmarried and/or queer and/or feminist and/or nonmonogamous and/or working class/escaped working class and/or rural or urban instead of suburban. We are mothers who adore our children, and our children are gorgeous beings of great potential. We didn't ask for permission to become who we are or to create the wonders that are our children. We must insist on a world in which doing so is not a punishable offense just as we must insist on a world in which all our reproductive freedoms are supported and protected.
When I was a teenager, Planned Parenthood sent a medical professional to my backwater county once a month. She set up shop in a local doctor's office and offered gynecological and contraceptive health care to young women who otherwise wouldn't have had any. Although I became sexually active before going to that monthly clinic, I did go and get on the pill. For years afterward, I felt I owed a great debt to Planned Parenthood for saving me from coping with an unplanned pregnancy and possibly motherhood while I was still in my teens. When I went away to college, I was completely alienated by the student health center, and a similarly alienated fellow student referred me to the local Planned Parenthood office. The nurse practitioner there had a good sense of humor, a gentle, competent hand, and a true gift for the healing arts. She was a woman comfortable in her lesbianism, and coming out to her and talking with her helped me become comfortable with my own queerness. I felt my debt to Planned Parenthood had grown.
A few years later, I moved to Kansas City, and thanks to that same nurse practitioner {hurray for the old dykes' network}, I got a job answering phones at the KC Planned Parenthood. In the way of non-profits, willing hands were put to work in a variety of ways, and I ended up being trained to work as an abortion counselor. The two years I spent helping women through the often difficult and challenging experience of ending a pregnancy taught me a great many things, not the least of which was the incredible importance of women's reproductive freedom of choice. While there, I saw women who had been anti-choice come to new realizations about these complex issues when their own circumstances brought them to choose abortion, and I saw women who remained vehemently anti-choice even as they had abortions themselves. While there, I learned about risking violence to provide care, and I learned that the care we provided was only an aspect of women's reproductive freedom of choice.
Unfortunately, reproductive freedom activism and activist organizations are often so besieged by anti-choice fanaticism that they lose sight of all the other aspects. They see access to abortion as a crisis, and the rest falls by the wayside. That is a very dangerous approach. The assumptions that underlie anti-choice rhetoric are the same as those that underlie involuntary sterilization and other punitive measures against mothers who dare to be poor and/or non-white. Fighting for abortion access is important, but if the fight is limited to that, it is doomed to fail. Reproductive freedom has to be fought for in all its aspects, and those underlying assumptions have to be challenged: Women's bodies are our own, not mere tools for the reproductive use of men. Motherhood should be supported by society. Poverty should be ameliorated, not criminalized. All children should be valued and provided access to necessities and resources.
Most of the mothers and their children I know wouldn't qualify for existence as such based on those underlying assumptions. We are poor and/or non-white and/or unmarried and/or queer and/or feminist and/or nonmonogamous and/or working class/escaped working class and/or rural or urban instead of suburban. We are mothers who adore our children, and our children are gorgeous beings of great potential. We didn't ask for permission to become who we are or to create the wonders that are our children. We must insist on a world in which doing so is not a punishable offense just as we must insist on a world in which all our reproductive freedoms are supported and protected.

4 Comments:
I do not visit your blog very often, but this is a beautiful entry. I have twice in my life helped women through abortions. Neither of the women was pregnant by me, but both knew me and felt that they could trust me for emotional and some financial support. It does seem that there is even less support for women who want to have a child than those who want to end a pregnancy, unless of course they are married.
What kinds of support would help? Is it of necessity a government problem, or is it a problem of cultural attitudes, or???
A complete overhaul in social and cultural attitudes about children and childrearing would be required, I think, to create the needed support for women and their children. Presently, children are viewed simultaneously as this luxury no woman is good enough to bear and as a nuisance no one without them wants to deal with or contribute to the support/rearing of. Universal healthcare, excellent public education, flexible work schedules and environments, affordable and accessible childcare, paid parental leave, decent housing, and excellent nutrition should be available to all parents and children. Canada and many European countries have come much closer to realizing these things than the U.S. has. The major shift is to a community perspective versus an individual one. If we as a society saw mothers and children as part of a community we are responsible for contributing to, if we saw children {regardless of whether they are related to us by blood or not} as our future, I think folks would be better able to commit to their well being.
Hell, we already pay nearly as much in taxes as the Scandinavian countries that have come closest to realizing these goals. We just need to direct that revenue to these areas instead of to corporate welfare and the military industrial prison complex.
And yes, janky, i think the bodily integrity argument is at the core of the issue even though neither pro- or anti-choice folks are really touching on it much. The government shouldn't be able to dictate to you what you can or can't do with your own body and health. period. The arguments of anti-choice folk are all rooted in erotophobic, misogynist, patriarchal bullshit, plain and simple.
But i'm ranting now. i'll stop.
Very well written!
thank you, trula, for the compliment.
thank you, janky, for smiling when thinking of my ranting voice. it's good to be thought of with a smile.
Post a Comment
<< Home