Wednesday, October 12, 2005

Chewing the Fat on Skinny: Body Criminality[1]

Chewing the Fat on Skinny: Body Criminality[1]
At around midnight, I’m standing on a corner in Oakland, California. Tonight’s array of queer performers was thought-provoking and challenging, but right now, I’m tired. I don’t want to contemplate or savor; I just want to go home and get in bed. That’s not an option just yet because I’m waiting for my lover, the maestro of this series of shows, to finish up the after-chores. So, I’m standing here on the corner, holding a bag full of greasy cheeseburger and a thick shake from the all night joint a block and a half from the venue.
A few feet from me, four people who were not in tonight’s audience are engaged in an energetic debate about what to do with themselves next. The three men want to go get something to eat, maybe pizza. The woman, who is blonde, pale, and thin enough to work the waif thing, insists that she can’t eat anything because she is “watching her weight”. She tells her companions, who could have been extras in “American Pie”, that it’s okay; she can just watch them eat.
The light changes, and I hurry away from them before I hear whether that resolution is accepted. The living metaphor of the whole occurrence rings through me: skinny white woman surrounded by white men juxtaposed with me – a woman whose photo could serve as an illustration of the word zaftig holding a cheeseburger and chocolate shake and standing alone. I’m clear that most of mainstream America would give her props for her self-denial and resulting thinness while pitying {or having contempt for} my lack of self-control {cheeseburger, shake}, the unavoidable result {thick figure}, and its just punishment {solitary nights}. My response, though, is quite the reverse. I am initially angry with this woman for being so weak as to govern herself according to pervasive, misogynist norms. Then, I am sad for her, for the joys I’m guessing she can’t know {the benefits of embracing body criminality}, so long as she’s policing herself so harshly.
Days later, I come across an article about the substantially higher suicide rate of women who have had breast implants as compared to women in general. The plastic surgeons quoted in the article are quick to deflect blame from themselves and onto the women. They say the suicidal women are largely afflicted with body dysmorphic disorder. They imply these crazy women are going to kill themselves anyway, so plastic surgeons might as well profit in the meanwhile. Nowhere in the article is there even the merest trace of contextualization or critical analysis. The tone of the article fairly hollers its innocent concern – why, oh, why do these women loathe their bodies so thoroughly as to commit suicide rather than live with their imperfections?! The author, and by extension, the imagined reader is appalled and mystified. This time, none of the anger I have is for the women so affected by pervasive, misogynist norms. All of it is directed at the cycle of cultural creation and reinforcement that sustains those absurdist norms. To borrow from domestic violence terminology, we need to break the cycle. More than a passing parallel exists between the two epistemologies. In both instances, women are bombarded with overt and covert messages that tell them they are bad, wrong, weak, and deserve to suffer. The messages are not empty threats. They are backed up with an array of negative reinforcements including fists in one context and the concerned query, “have you gained weight?”/ endless screaming advertising in another. The hurled curse “fat bitch” is effective in both. Just as escaping an abusive relationship requires the psychological and emotional resources necessary to reject constant conditioning of inadequacy, so, too, does escaping societal beauty norms. Just as an abuse survivor may need to spend time learning or relearning that she is not stupid or destined to fail, so, too, may a woman need to make a conscious effort to see beauty, in herself and others, that doesn’t appear in Vogue, even the “Shape” issue.
Sometimes, it’s easier to begin with others. Look at women you know personally. Your first glance will likely be automatically filled with criticisms rooted in those norms, though it will probably be a kinder eye than you would turn on yourself. Now, take another look, and this time, make an effort to lift the veil of societal expectations and see the beauty of the body before you. Give her a compliment culled from this endeavor. When you get comfortable seeing other women this way, begin adjusting how you look at yourself. Do it in front of the mirror. Speak your praises aloud. I’m serious. I began doing this years ago, and the difference between how I look to myself through the veil {and it still falls over my eyes sometimes} and how I look to myself when I’m celebrating the beauty that’s there is astounding. I’m not suggesting this is an effortless undertaking, I’m just saying its worth the effort. It began working for me initially when I turned unveiled eyes on the women in my family. I loved them, and I wanted to see their beauty. Opening my eyes to them, what I saw was an incredible gift to me. Similar gifts rain on me now each time I can see the beauty of people in my life, of people on the street who will never grace the runways, and that rain satisfies a deep and basic thirst.
That is only one of the benefits of body criminality mentioned above. Here’s some more: enjoying food when you eat it {not distracted by counting calories consumed}, enjoying physical exertion for its own sake {not focused on burning calories}, reveling in the pleasures of the flesh {instead of leaving on a nightgown or doing without a lover’s touch out of shame}, wearing what the hell you feel like and strutting all of your stuff {instead of limiting your wardrobe to clothes that “hide” your “flaws” or are “appropriate for your body type”}.
The list goes on, but perhaps the most important benefit is making much better use of all of the energy you once squandered on body fascism. Yes, creating and maintaining the outlaw attitude necessary to relish your body criminality requires energy, too, but those processes actually nourish you, too, rather than just sucking away your vitality like somatophobia invariably does. While body fascism is a rigid construct requiring an unattainable goal, body criminality, when embraced, is flexible and evolving and can offer daily rewards. Friends and lovers who are proud body criminals {which isn’t about their actual physicality, but about attitude} can be a huge help in this endeavor. Hearing sincere praise for your abundant curves {or slim lines}, seeing genuine appreciation for your beauty in another person’s eyes , feeling admiration of the “flaws” you have “inappropriately” displayed – these are precious things, things to be sought, savored, cultivated.
Now, you may have been surprised by my mention of praising slim lines, but that’s all part of embracing body criminality, too. To quote one of my favorite movies {yes, I am partial to improbable romantic comedies, but that’s another essay}, “Le’ me ‘splain. No, there is too much. Le’ me sum up.” Okay, so cultivating impossible perfectionist obsessions is a form social control {How much less energy do you have to challenge oppressive status quos when you’re exhausting yourself chasing that runway silhouette? Perhaps more importantly, how entitled do you feel to challenge anything when you see yourself as weak and out of control?} and a profit margin staple {how many billions do Americans spend on diet books, pills, gym memberships, cosmetic surgery {which is a form of body modification. shit.}, “health” foods, et cetera? These expenditures are, of course, appalling in their own right: people paying to starve when much of the planet struggles to eat just ain’t cool. Even so, both of those ends can be met with just about any body raised to the ideal, and they can even be met at the expensive of women who come as close as humanly possible to the mode of the moment. While the waif presently rules the runways, women who are born with slender genes are still struggling with what they perceive as imperfections – flat chested? No man will want you. Better get breast implants. Too skinny? Better buy some weight-gain supplements.
Hell, there are as many different beauty norms as there are cultures. No, more because each culture’s ideals change with time and influences. Shortly after the Industrial Revolution in Europe, the feminine beauty ideal included a plumpness that denoted enough to eat and leisure. I’m thinking it was more acceptable for women to be more substantial then because “proper” women were expected to be fettered by 80 pounds of under and over garments, corsets, high button shoes, very large hats, and maybe bustles. Nowadays, I’m thinking waifs {with breast implants, of course} are presented as the ideal in part because their very thinness is expected to fetter them in a similar fashion. They are small; they are hungry. They must, then, be frail and weak. I know my own discomfort with slender people is rooted in a notion of vulnerability learned and resisted as the scrawny child I was. {Please, don’t get the idea that I’m a big woman because I’m trying to protect my inner child in a fortress of fat. Though I’m a big woman for a lot of reasons, that’s not one of them. Trust me.} Even given my own issues with skinny, I can still appreciate the reality of strength and beauty in a small package when presented with it. No sense in trading one veil for another.
A clear eye – that brings us back to the broad spectrum of body criminality. If you want your eyes to open to beauty, be prepared for the beauty of slim hips to be in there with the beauty of big asses and sagging breasts. It’ll be different with unveiled eyes, though. You’ll be able to tell your long, lean friend that beauty shines in her body without any implants or weight gain supplements. You won’t be saying to yourself, “Bitch, you’ve got the ideal. Shut up already.” You’ll be able to say to the petite friend who insists she’s fat that she’s gorgeous just the way she is instead of swallowing the caustic inquiry about what women larger than her are if she’s “disgustingly obese.”
Your new eyes will also see any men in your life differently. Yes, body fascism is a tool of patriarchy, but men fall victim to it, too. Gay men’s culture has reflected this for decades, and now, straight men are feeling the burn, too. In all honesty, some part of me took some satisfaction in this phenomenon when it first came to my attention. However, that quickly gave way to irritation and yes, sadness: more wasted energy, more humans missing out on really enjoying their bodies. Body fascism and body criminality encompasses folks regardless of sex or gender.
Sexual orientation, class, race, age, and physical ability, among other aspects of identity and experience, are also, of course, part of what shapes both body fascism and our experiences of it. That Industrial Revolution thing I mentioned earlier – that was for the brand new middle class. Nowadays, us fat girls are presumed to be poor because everyone knows the poor and the fat are both lazy and undisciplined. If you’re a voluptuous black woman, the mainstream myth is that you don’t have body image issues, regardless of your actual lived experience. Much to my dismay, many queer women also police themselves and each other in this fashion. In my experience, being a big woman with a chronic illness can make dealing with medical personnel extremely wearing when they all too often spew fat-phobic inanities at me. Our youth obsessed culture’s steady reduction of the age of the face of sanctioned beauty toys with illegality, and women from their twenties onward are encouraged to loathe any physical evidence that they’ve been alive for more than 15 years. Of course, many of us live with more than one of these issues complicating our relationships with our bodies. I definitely want to give props to and offer recommendations of folks who have addresses these issues in their various combinations before, elsewhere, at greater length: Fat?So! by Marilyn Wann, Minding the Body edited by . . . , Fat Is a Feminist Issue I and II by Susie Orbach, “Fat Dyke” zine, some of the essays in Brazen Femme edited by . . ., Listen Up! edited by Barbara Findlay, To Be Real edited by Rebecca Walker, Adios, Barbie edited by . . ., Colonize This! edited by . . ., Miscegenation Blues edited by . . ., and Ms Nomy Lamm’s everything.
I have learned from and been nourished by these women’s shared writings, my chosen and blood family, and my own efforts. The gist of embracing body criminality, for me, is appreciation. This is my body. Every joy or pain, every ecstasy, every accomplishment I can recall came to me through this body. Although most organized religions are rife with somatophobia {and contribute to body fascism thereby}, “I am that I am” is actually a fabulous approach to ourselves, body and soul. My body is beautiful because it is. It is that simple. Of course, it can be a lengthy, complicated, continuous journey getting there, but it’s so worth it. Trust.
Start now. Your beauty is.
[1] Body criminality exists on two levels. First is the crime of violating prescribed cultural norms. Mainstream American culture's present norm is, in general terms, skinny, tall, white, big breasted &/or muscular, able-bodied, young, and middle/upper class looking. Body criminals, therefore, are all of us whose physiology cannot be squeezed into that narrow prescription. On a second level, body criminals are also all of us who reject that prescription, embracing and celebrating a much broader concept of beauty, regardless of our physiologies.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home