Wednesday, October 12, 2005

Loyalty and Betrayal: Class Transgressions

Loyalty and Betrayal: Class Transgressions
by Janine M. deManda
In the summer of 2000, I had a fellowship as a law clerk at a social justice legal organization in Detroit. In keeping with our annual tradition, my mom was coming to spend her vacation with me, wherever I happened to be. One of my coworkers invited me and my mom to her 4th of July barbecue. On July 3rd, Mom and I drove across the border to Ontario. We visited Windsor and drove around the countryside and went to the lakeshore. It got late, so we decided to stay the night. The next day, we put on our travel-stained clothes and headed back to the States. By the time we got back, we were already late for the barbecue. Though Mom would have preferred to go back by my place to wash and change first, I convinced her it would be better just to go on to the barbecue since it was closer. The only person I knew at the barbecue was my coworker, but she was someone I enjoyed working with who clearly had some sense. Unfortunately, no one else at the barbecue did, at least not with regard to issues of class and respectful interaction.
My mom is a factory worker. In addition, she also has experience under her belt waiting tables, working cattle, tending bar, painting signs, digging graves, pumping gas, and selling Avon. She grew up in the projects in the South Bronx. When I was a kid, she moved us back to rural Missouri where her mother was raised, and I grew up 200 hundred miles from everywhere. Poverty is, nonetheless, poverty. Lucky for me, my mom had a knack for surviving it with some sense of humor intact.
The rest of the folks at the barbecue were solidly middle class – lawyers, college professors, business professionals. If any of them had ever been anything else, they didn't show a hint of it that day. After an agonizing hour or so of patronizing small talk, my mom went to the car for a smoke. When I checked on her, she asked that I tell the hostess that she wasn't feeling well, so we could leave. I went back, made our excuses, and we left. The whole experience left me angry and frustrated to the point of tears, and I still carry those feelings with me. My mother is one of the wisest, funniest, best people I have ever known, and I wanted to smack the hell out of that backyard full of liberal democrats talking down their privilege at her like she was a simple-minded unfortunate. But, my anger and frustration wasn't only with them. I was furious with myself for having exposed my mom to such hurtful idiocy; I was frustrated with my incapacity to create a space in which my working poor self and my over-educated self and all our companions could respectfully coexist. To this day, I carry that barbecue like a wound that won't heal. To this day, I feel it as a betrayal of my mother's trust in me. To this day, I have absolutely no doubt, not one of the other attendees has even the remotest understanding that they did anything wrong.
When I was twenty years old, I gave myself a debilitating dose of internalized classism. It wasn't until years later that I recognized what I had done. It's years later still, and each day includes ongoing resistance to that particularly toxic drug.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home