Waste Not, Want Not: Infestations in the Academy
Waste Not, Want Not: Infestations in the Academy
By Janine M. deManda
When I was a kid, my mom's brother would come visit a few times a year. He lived in Marceline, Missouri, a metropolis of a few thousand people seventy miles to the south of Putnam County, the sixty by fifty sprawling miles of sparsely populated country where me, my mom, my maternal grandparents, and an assortment of other relatives lived. Most times, when my uncle came to visit, he wanted to hunt something – whatever was in season or didn't have a season. Unlike many of the city hunters that plagued us during deer season, my uncle didn't leave the meat to rot after claiming some phallic-substitute trophy. Best of all, in my opinion, he taught me how to track – which animal belonged to which print, how big the animal likely was based on the depth of the print and the softness of the ground, age of the print based on how it had weathered, when it last rained, and so on.
Of course, he wasn't completely ideal. His answer to not wasting the meat was usually to give the game to my grandmother to clean and cook, but at least people were nourished by his kill. One visit, though, none of us ate what my uncle had successfully hunted. That time, he announced on arrival that he wanted to go rabbit hunting, and he refused to be dissuaded. My mom tried to explain to him that there was no sense in hunting rabbits that year because they were full of warbles[1], but he wouldn't listen. He insisted that warbles were just another version of snipes[2] and headed out anyway. A few hours later, he came back with a mess of rabbits which he gutted and skinned in my grandma's backyard. Upon doing so, he discovered that my mom had not, in fact, been talking shit. The carcasses were rendered essentially inedible by the infestation of warble larvae. The hunt and the hunted were wasted.
The governing practices of academe remind me of nothing so much as those warble-infested rabbit carcasses my uncle had thought could feed us. The general principles have good potential that has been corrupted by secondary principles the actors in question refuse to acknowledge or even believe in, if at all, only superficially. Like the rabbits my uncle thought he was hunting, academe is, in the abstract, a good thing. So, I'll grant the long-ago inventors of institutions of higher learning some credit for realizing and pointing out that rabbits could be good food. Unfortunately, like the rabbits my uncle actually brought home that day, the policies and practices presented to me in their modern incarnations are too infested with corruption to offer anything truly nourishing.
Now, as a historian[3], if in no other capacity, I advocate for individual and collective knowledge of the past – not just events of the past, but ideas of the past and the contexts in which they were rooted. I'm clear that it's important to look at goodly portions of social, intellectual, legal, and cultural history if for no other reason than to provide an abject past we can congratulate ourselves on moving beyond.[4] Other reasons, though, can include remembering that some wisdoms hold true over time, that not all that is worthy was born fifteen minutes ago, that where we came from can profoundly shape where we are and where we're going. Sometimes, in other words, amazing insights can be gleaned from histories and historical documents. Sometimes. Not always. Within the confines of the Ivory Tower of Academe, not often.
After nearly two decades in institutions of learning and, uh, higher learning, I feel I have a good grasp on the biases and isms that mine every one of the, um, level playing fields[5] of the academy. Though I appreciate the avenues of awareness that have been opened in my life, I can say with a fair accuracy that most of them have been opened despite, not because of the academy, and most have been opened outside, not within the confines of that fabled tower. Not only are all of the traditional disciplines in general and the institutions in specific screamingly sexist, inherently imperialist, and cavalierly racist, their very modality is the essence of classism. Been there; had that disappointment; got my jaded card punched. Three times, maybe four.
Though I am approaching membership in the platinum club for the jaded,[6] I still have a disproportionate share of outrage and indignation. As a result, my time in the classrooms of various incarnations of the Academy has been rather fraught with frustration and conflict. Initially, a great deal of that was about my right to even be present. As a working class, mixed blood, queer woman, I am heir to several histories of exclusion from those hallowed halls and from the ritual texts used therein.
Later and now, I'm exquisitely clear how unwelcome upstarts like myself are. The silencing, the homogenizing, even the carefully coded praise all insist on the maintenance of status quos designed for the benefit of folks who resemble me not at all. Fortunately, the long trek from shame to disobedience has included the blessed voices of many who do offer mirrors to me.[7] Many of them, like my grandmother, speak without degrees. Many of them raise in wisdom voices that have never echoed off those ivory walls.
For what it's worth, there are growing numbers of scholars within academe who are working from within to reroute the flow of those status quos, so perhaps in some hoped-for future, unlicensed voices like my grandmother's and others' can be heard within those ivory walls without condescension, dismissal, or patronizing earnestness. Perhaps in some future, critical thinking and the acquisition of knowledge it enables will be honored everywhere. Perhaps those ivory walls will come a'tumblin' down. Perhaps.
As a good friend is wont to remind me, my time served in the Academy gives me a license to speak. For a goodly part of my twenties, I thought I'd use that license to do that flow-changing-from-the-inside thing, but I changed my mind. I'm glad those folks are there; make no mistake. I wish them well, but that's their rabbit hunt. I trust they'll be able to bring home something edible.
As for me, I'm after some very different prey, and I trust both my uncle's shared tracking knowledge and example of bad judgment will serve my hunt well. I wasn't hungry enough to eat around warbles when I was a kid; I sure the hell wasn't all those years in the tower, and I'm far from it now. If it hadn't been for those unlicensed and upstart voices, I'd've starved long ago. I'd like to give them, give us something back, and though this essay is part of that, it's not all by any means. So, I don't have time to waste on cold trails or within cold walls. I do want to take a moment to say you needn't discount your own knowing if you've never been to the tower, if you've been and felt silenced, if you've been and remain. The world is wide outside those walls; the hunting is far better out here, and we have always been more than can be kept in there.
[1] Warbles are subdermal parasites that can afflict wild game, domestic animals, and humans. Primarily, though, it is rodents that are most frequently infected – rabbits, chipmunks, squirrels, et cetera. Warbles are the larval stage of the botfly and feed off the muscular tissue of the host. Upon maturation, they leave the host by breaking through the dermis. A typical warble is roughly the size of a quarter. Hosts are sometimes overwhelmed by the parasites and their effects and die. If properly cooked, infested meat is safe, but not, at the advanced stage, pleasant to eat.
[2] Snipe hunting is a familiar joke where I grew up. Ain't no such thing as snipes, and that's what makes them such ideal prey on a hunt whose sole purpose is to make fools out of city folks. An actual snipe hunt involves a clueless urban dweller or two, a pillow case, an isolated, preferably wooded spot, night, and a ruthless rural dweller or two. A metaphoric snipe hunt could involve any activity guaranteed to be fruitless, like, oh, say, looking for redeeming qualities in the traditions of exclusion in the academy.
[3] Having been challenged on my claim to this moniker, let me just clarify that I have a B.A. in history, and I completed the coursework, though not the thesis, for an M.A. in the discipline as well. Frankly, though, I don't think either is a necessary qualification. My grandmother was a historian, not because of any degrees bestowed upon her – she had none, but because she was a keeper of histories. In her instance, it was the histories of our family, but that is, after all, the root of the discipline, however contorted the limbs have become.
[4] This is sarcasm. I don't have a firm conviction that humanity, much less the world, is inherently and exponentially better off just because time has passed. If history teaches anything, it's that we homo sapiens, no matter how earnest, have a remarkable talent for repeating mistakes and maintaining injustice.
[5] Again, with the sarcasm.
[6] Not sarcasm this time, just the truth wittily rendered. Or something like that.
[7] Thanks be to and for my mother, Laura Miller; my grandmother, Joyce Koenig; my great aunt, Dora Lee Behrendt; my sisterfriends Heather Clark and Kelly Greer; Audre Lorde, Leslie Feinberg, Dorothy Allison, Joan Nestle, Amber Hollibaugh, bell hooks, Jewelle Gomez, Cherie Moraga, Gloria Anzaldua, Inga Muscio, and many others.
By Janine M. deManda
When I was a kid, my mom's brother would come visit a few times a year. He lived in Marceline, Missouri, a metropolis of a few thousand people seventy miles to the south of Putnam County, the sixty by fifty sprawling miles of sparsely populated country where me, my mom, my maternal grandparents, and an assortment of other relatives lived. Most times, when my uncle came to visit, he wanted to hunt something – whatever was in season or didn't have a season. Unlike many of the city hunters that plagued us during deer season, my uncle didn't leave the meat to rot after claiming some phallic-substitute trophy. Best of all, in my opinion, he taught me how to track – which animal belonged to which print, how big the animal likely was based on the depth of the print and the softness of the ground, age of the print based on how it had weathered, when it last rained, and so on.
Of course, he wasn't completely ideal. His answer to not wasting the meat was usually to give the game to my grandmother to clean and cook, but at least people were nourished by his kill. One visit, though, none of us ate what my uncle had successfully hunted. That time, he announced on arrival that he wanted to go rabbit hunting, and he refused to be dissuaded. My mom tried to explain to him that there was no sense in hunting rabbits that year because they were full of warbles[1], but he wouldn't listen. He insisted that warbles were just another version of snipes[2] and headed out anyway. A few hours later, he came back with a mess of rabbits which he gutted and skinned in my grandma's backyard. Upon doing so, he discovered that my mom had not, in fact, been talking shit. The carcasses were rendered essentially inedible by the infestation of warble larvae. The hunt and the hunted were wasted.
The governing practices of academe remind me of nothing so much as those warble-infested rabbit carcasses my uncle had thought could feed us. The general principles have good potential that has been corrupted by secondary principles the actors in question refuse to acknowledge or even believe in, if at all, only superficially. Like the rabbits my uncle thought he was hunting, academe is, in the abstract, a good thing. So, I'll grant the long-ago inventors of institutions of higher learning some credit for realizing and pointing out that rabbits could be good food. Unfortunately, like the rabbits my uncle actually brought home that day, the policies and practices presented to me in their modern incarnations are too infested with corruption to offer anything truly nourishing.
Now, as a historian[3], if in no other capacity, I advocate for individual and collective knowledge of the past – not just events of the past, but ideas of the past and the contexts in which they were rooted. I'm clear that it's important to look at goodly portions of social, intellectual, legal, and cultural history if for no other reason than to provide an abject past we can congratulate ourselves on moving beyond.[4] Other reasons, though, can include remembering that some wisdoms hold true over time, that not all that is worthy was born fifteen minutes ago, that where we came from can profoundly shape where we are and where we're going. Sometimes, in other words, amazing insights can be gleaned from histories and historical documents. Sometimes. Not always. Within the confines of the Ivory Tower of Academe, not often.
After nearly two decades in institutions of learning and, uh, higher learning, I feel I have a good grasp on the biases and isms that mine every one of the, um, level playing fields[5] of the academy. Though I appreciate the avenues of awareness that have been opened in my life, I can say with a fair accuracy that most of them have been opened despite, not because of the academy, and most have been opened outside, not within the confines of that fabled tower. Not only are all of the traditional disciplines in general and the institutions in specific screamingly sexist, inherently imperialist, and cavalierly racist, their very modality is the essence of classism. Been there; had that disappointment; got my jaded card punched. Three times, maybe four.
Though I am approaching membership in the platinum club for the jaded,[6] I still have a disproportionate share of outrage and indignation. As a result, my time in the classrooms of various incarnations of the Academy has been rather fraught with frustration and conflict. Initially, a great deal of that was about my right to even be present. As a working class, mixed blood, queer woman, I am heir to several histories of exclusion from those hallowed halls and from the ritual texts used therein.
Later and now, I'm exquisitely clear how unwelcome upstarts like myself are. The silencing, the homogenizing, even the carefully coded praise all insist on the maintenance of status quos designed for the benefit of folks who resemble me not at all. Fortunately, the long trek from shame to disobedience has included the blessed voices of many who do offer mirrors to me.[7] Many of them, like my grandmother, speak without degrees. Many of them raise in wisdom voices that have never echoed off those ivory walls.
For what it's worth, there are growing numbers of scholars within academe who are working from within to reroute the flow of those status quos, so perhaps in some hoped-for future, unlicensed voices like my grandmother's and others' can be heard within those ivory walls without condescension, dismissal, or patronizing earnestness. Perhaps in some future, critical thinking and the acquisition of knowledge it enables will be honored everywhere. Perhaps those ivory walls will come a'tumblin' down. Perhaps.
As a good friend is wont to remind me, my time served in the Academy gives me a license to speak. For a goodly part of my twenties, I thought I'd use that license to do that flow-changing-from-the-inside thing, but I changed my mind. I'm glad those folks are there; make no mistake. I wish them well, but that's their rabbit hunt. I trust they'll be able to bring home something edible.
As for me, I'm after some very different prey, and I trust both my uncle's shared tracking knowledge and example of bad judgment will serve my hunt well. I wasn't hungry enough to eat around warbles when I was a kid; I sure the hell wasn't all those years in the tower, and I'm far from it now. If it hadn't been for those unlicensed and upstart voices, I'd've starved long ago. I'd like to give them, give us something back, and though this essay is part of that, it's not all by any means. So, I don't have time to waste on cold trails or within cold walls. I do want to take a moment to say you needn't discount your own knowing if you've never been to the tower, if you've been and felt silenced, if you've been and remain. The world is wide outside those walls; the hunting is far better out here, and we have always been more than can be kept in there.
[1] Warbles are subdermal parasites that can afflict wild game, domestic animals, and humans. Primarily, though, it is rodents that are most frequently infected – rabbits, chipmunks, squirrels, et cetera. Warbles are the larval stage of the botfly and feed off the muscular tissue of the host. Upon maturation, they leave the host by breaking through the dermis. A typical warble is roughly the size of a quarter. Hosts are sometimes overwhelmed by the parasites and their effects and die. If properly cooked, infested meat is safe, but not, at the advanced stage, pleasant to eat.
[2] Snipe hunting is a familiar joke where I grew up. Ain't no such thing as snipes, and that's what makes them such ideal prey on a hunt whose sole purpose is to make fools out of city folks. An actual snipe hunt involves a clueless urban dweller or two, a pillow case, an isolated, preferably wooded spot, night, and a ruthless rural dweller or two. A metaphoric snipe hunt could involve any activity guaranteed to be fruitless, like, oh, say, looking for redeeming qualities in the traditions of exclusion in the academy.
[3] Having been challenged on my claim to this moniker, let me just clarify that I have a B.A. in history, and I completed the coursework, though not the thesis, for an M.A. in the discipline as well. Frankly, though, I don't think either is a necessary qualification. My grandmother was a historian, not because of any degrees bestowed upon her – she had none, but because she was a keeper of histories. In her instance, it was the histories of our family, but that is, after all, the root of the discipline, however contorted the limbs have become.
[4] This is sarcasm. I don't have a firm conviction that humanity, much less the world, is inherently and exponentially better off just because time has passed. If history teaches anything, it's that we homo sapiens, no matter how earnest, have a remarkable talent for repeating mistakes and maintaining injustice.
[5] Again, with the sarcasm.
[6] Not sarcasm this time, just the truth wittily rendered. Or something like that.
[7] Thanks be to and for my mother, Laura Miller; my grandmother, Joyce Koenig; my great aunt, Dora Lee Behrendt; my sisterfriends Heather Clark and Kelly Greer; Audre Lorde, Leslie Feinberg, Dorothy Allison, Joan Nestle, Amber Hollibaugh, bell hooks, Jewelle Gomez, Cherie Moraga, Gloria Anzaldua, Inga Muscio, and many others.

2 Comments:
She's doing well, and she said I could pass along her email address when she gets one again.
yeah, i have nostalgia for the ol' home place, but i have sadness as well. there are things i can only have there that i miss, but there are also things i could never have there that i missed before i even left - were why i left. ::sigh:: life is complicated.
Post a Comment
<< Home